Compassion or Consequences?

Define the right choice for any circumstance. Tell me where we draw the line between compassion and just deserts. I am certain this question has run through the minds of many legislators and political viewers alike as they observed Gov. Perry's bill mandating girls of a certain age get vaccinated for HPV get shot down and state Sen. Bob Deuell's needle exchange legislation being tossed around. Recently Gov. Perry compared these two issues. He believes that there is no difference in the arguments for or against either piece of legislation. Some believe each has the potential to encourage a bad activity (illegal drug use and promiscuity.) One political blogger comments on this comparison on his blog Grits For Breakfast. He observes that the biggest difference is cost. The needle exchange program is done by non-profit organizations while the vaccination program would be financed by tax payers. Otherwise, both pieces of legislation could potentially save many lives and a lot of money. At first glance at least, I would support the needle exchange program. It has the potential to bring drug users into rehabilitation programs. But it all boils down to the question should we let those who have made wrong choices face their consequences, or should we show some compassion? Grits provides many additional links to information pages for the needle exchange program. I'd encourage you to read his blog and form your own decision.